Copyright notice

This article is from the Dictionary of North Carolina Biography, 6 volumes, edited by William S. Powell. Copyright ©1979-1996 by the University of North Carolina Press. Used by permission of the publisher. For personal use and not for further distribution. Please submit permission requests for other use directly to the publisher.

Printer-friendly page
Average: 2.4 (8 votes)

Alston, Philip

by Claiborne T. Smith, Jr., 1979

ca. 1745–91

"House in the Horseshoe." Available from Flickr Commons.Philip Alston, revolutionary patriot, was born in Halifax County, the son of Joseph John Alston and his first wife, Elisabeth Chancy. In 1772 he bought four thousand acres of land in a horseshoe-shaped bend in the Deep River in Cumberland (later Moore) County. He moved to this tract and is thought to have built the fine colonial house, called "The House in the Horseshoe," yet standing there. Alston began to purchase more land and by 1777 appeared on the tax lists with sixty-five hundred acres. He achieved prominence in his new home; with the onset of the Revolution in 1775, he was appointed second major of the Cumberland Militia. In 1776 he was appointed a justice of the county court and promoted to lieutenant colonel of the militia. Elected to the House of Commons as a representative from Cumberland in the fall of 1777, Alston was granted a leave of absence in December to give full time to military affairs. In 1778, after controversy, he was promoted to colonel. Little is known of his actual military service, but in March of 1779 General John Ashe reported that Colonel Alston had been taken prisoner at Briar Creek in Georgia. On his release he was involved in local skirmishes with David Fanning, the notorious Tory marauder of nearby Chatham County. Tradition says that, in 1781, Fanning trapped Alston in his home. As Fanning began setting fire to the house, Mrs. Alston emerged with a flag of truce and her husband was led away captive.

With the formation of Moore County in 1784, Philip Alston was appointed justice and became the first clerk of court. Having been elected to the state senate, he resigned the clerkship on 23 Feb. 1785, "promising that George Glascock should act as deputy until James Alston (his son) comes of age"; the court appointed James Alston clerk. Philip Alston was elected to the senate again the following year.

The records reveal a dark side to Alston's character. Even before the Revolution, Philip Alston, styled "gunsmith," was accused of counterfeiting. In September 1777, Colonel Robert Rowan, a prominent patriot in Cumberland, wrote Governor Richard Caswell, criticizing Alston's political activities in the county and stating that "he seems to rule them all, and a greater tyrant is not upon the face of the earth according to his power" and that "about two or three years ago no gentleman with the least regard for his character would have kept this hectoring, domineering person company." In December 1785 testimony was presented to the assembly that Alston had murdered one Thomas Taylor. As Taylor had been a Tory and Alston was commanding a corps of militia in the service of the state at the time of Taylor's death, the committee of the assembly thought he should not be tried for murder. He was accordingly pardoned by Governor Richard Caswell.

In a few months there was further evidence of the colonel's violent nature. According to the court minutes of Moore County, on 20 Feb. 1786, "Philip Alston in a very abusive manner treated George Glascock, he the said Alston then sitting as Justice, on a bench." Glascock, a native of Virginia and first cousin to George Washington, had been appointed deputy clerk of court when Alston resigned. Deep-seated enmity developed between the two men. Glascock contested Alston's reelection to the senate in 1786 but lost. In May 1787 a number of citizens from Moore, probably led by Glascock, successfully petitioned the assembly to have Alston removed as justice of the peace; three months later Glascock was murdered. Evidence suggested that Alston ordered his slave Dave to commit the crime. Dave was seized, imprisoned, and released on bond; on 21 Aug. 1787, Alston forfeited a £250 bail when Dave failed to appear. That Alston himself was imprisoned for his part in the murder is attested by a note in the Fayetteville Gazette of 1 Dec. 1790; "Broke gaol on the 5th instant, Philip Alston, late of Moore County, committed as an accessory to the murder of George Glascock." In less than a year, Alston himself was dead; on 24 Nov. 1791 his son James qualified as administrator of his estate. Tradition says he fled to Tennessee and was there murdered by the runaway Dave.

Before leaving Halifax County, Philip Alston married Temperance, the second daughter of Drew Smith of the Scotland Neck section. In his will in 1762, Smith entailed a tract of land of four hundred acres on the Roanoke to his daughter Temperance. The Alstons sold this land in 1789, and James Alston, "eldest son and heir, joined to break the entail." James Alston married Mary Wilcox of Fayetteville and represented Chatham County in the legislature in 1800. Later he moved to Telfair County, Ga. According to family records, Philip Alston and his wife had three other sons and a daughter. John, the second son, who was mentioned in the will of his grandfather in Halifax county in 1778, moved to Fairfield County, S.C., where he left descendants. Philip, Jr., moved to Jackson, Tenn. There is no record of the fourth son, Drew. The only daughter, Mary Drew (b. 12 Jan. 1784), married in 1799 William Carroll. After he died without issue, she married William Harris and had with him three children, one of whom, Sarah, in 1832 married Albert Pickett, the historian of Alabama.

References:

The Deeds and Wills of the County of Halifax (North Carolina State Archives, Raleigh).

Joseph A. Groves, The Alstons and Allstons of North and South Carolina (1901).

Blackwell P. Robinson, A History of Moore County, N.C. (1956).

Additional Resources:

Letter from Robert Rowan to Richard Caswell, Rowan, Robert, September 18, 1777, Volume 11, Pages 626-631, UNC Libraries: https://docsouth.unc.edu/csr/index.html/document/csr11-0538

"House in the Horseshoe: ." NC Historic Sites, NC Office of Archives & History: http://www.nchistoricsites.org/horsesho/palston.htm.

NC Patriots 1775-1783: Their Own Words, Volume 2, Part 1, By J.D. Lewis: Availble from GoogleBooks

The State Records of North Carolina, Volume 17: Available from GoogleBooks

Image Credits:

"House in the Horseshoe." November 27, 2012. Available from: Flickr Commons, https://www.flickr.com/photos/ncculture/8224667136/ (accessed January 8, 2013).

Origin - location: 

Comments

Oh My, an editor on Wikipedia just took down all my edits and mis-information corrections on Philip Alston the Counterfeiter's page. I am livid! So now I guess the two cousins will stay combined.
And the one person who actually has over 30 years research on him can not add all the correct or missing information to his page and define the difference between the Two Philip Alston's.
Wow!
Tammy

I always want to tell you I appreciate your page! I am the 5th Great Great Granddaughter of Counterfeiter Philip Alston the 1st Cousin to The Philip Alston in this sketch.

I have referred people to this sketch too many times to count when they mix the two first cousins up and combine them as one person. They simply don't believe me unless they see they are totally different people with your article. Reguardless of the amount of Documents I give them to prove it. They simply just don't read them and believe what they want until they read your page. Sense it is a University of North Carolina Page they believe you rather than me! But I am extremely grateful for that, but wish I had some credibility for my 30 plus years of travel and research into my family history. I am currently wrighting a few books on my family as well. I am a self proclaimed, but justly (I think) an expert on my family genealogy.

I also wanted to note that Your Col. Philip Alston, Probably did get confused way back then with his 1st cousin "Philip Alston The Counterfeiter" and even back then, but was probably proven innocent when they realized it was his first cousin and not he was the Counterfeiter. He was probably mistaken by name for his equally famous cousin and probably accused of counterfeiting not only the name but they were 1st cousins by way of their father's being brothers and of the same family but different lines. I believe you also left out the story of him being shot in his bed in 1791, but maybe you didn't want to mention that.

I had to correct Wikipekia so many times on my Philip Alston the counterfeiter its for combining the two men (1st cousins) (Whig) Col. Philip Alston and The Cave in the Rock Counterfeiter Philip Alston (Tory)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_Alston_(counterfeiter)#Early_life_in_South_Carolina%2C_North_Carolina%2C_and_Virginia

The same with mixing their wives, just drives me crazy. Books have even been written combining the two cousins as one. Even James Dromgoole and Alexander Dromgoole's children get mixed up! By the way the Gr Granddaughter of Alexander Dromgoole and Elizabeth Smith is still alive and in her 90's I was going to visit her and tape her memories, but Covid has stopped that process for now. I hope she continues to survive until we can record her history in person. Any help with this is appreciated, just email me. As well all she wants in return is a DAR applied for in her name for her which I promised to do when I can get there. DAR as well has her Gr Grandfather listed as James Dromgoole which I can prove is incorrect, but just the same too many people combined the two William Alexander Dromgooles and just choose James Dromgoole to be the father of our line and DAR accepted it, I am hoping they will see the light with Documented proof James was not our lines ancestor.

Contact me if you want to help me keep the History correct and fill in some blanks, either way!

Sincerely, History and Genealogy nut,
Tammy Fishburn Post
Granddaughter of Catherine "Kitty" "Louis" Dromgoole
4th Gr Granddaughter of Alexander Dromgoole
5th Gr Granddaughter of Counterfeiter Philip Alston and Milly McCoy/McKay

Hello Tammy,

Wow! Thank you for sharing all of your research with the NCpedia viewers.

Molly Goldston, NC Government & Heritage Library

I found this history on Philip Alston very interesting. My fourth great grandfather William Barrett (b. 1754) served under Philip Alston during the Revolutionary War as evidenced in his pension records. Records show he was a dragoon and later a captain. After the war, when Moore County was created he served as one of the first justices there and a street in Carthage, NC is named after him. He named his first son John Alston Barrett (b. 1790) - the assumption is that it was in honor of Philip Alston with whom he served. I wondered if there are any documents to connect William Barrett more closely with Philip Alston.

Add a comment

PLEASE NOTE: NCpedia provides the comments feature as a way for viewers to engage with the resources. Comments are not published until reviewed by NCpedia editors at the State Library of NC, and the editors reserve the right to not publish any comment submitted that is considered inappropriate for this resource. NCpedia will not publish personal contact information in comments, questions, or responses. If you would like a reply by email, note that some email servers, such as public school accounts, are blocked from accepting messages from outside email servers or domains. If you prefer not to leave an email address, check back at your NCpedia comment for a reply. Please allow one business day for replies from NCpedia. Complete guidelines are available at https://ncpedia.org/about.