Copyright notice

This article is from the Dictionary of North Carolina Biography, 6 volumes, edited by William S. Powell. Copyright ©1979-1996 by the University of North Carolina Press. Used by permission of the publisher. For personal use and not for further distribution. Please submit permission requests for other use directly to the publisher.

Is anything in this article factually incorrect? Please submit a comment.

Printer-friendly page
No votes yet

Tucker, Joel W.

by Larry E. Tise, 1996


Joel W. Tucker, Methodist clergyman and controversialist, a native of Virginia, was one of those individuals who appear from virtually unknown origins, reveal a flash of brilliance, and then disappear in obscurity. In 1845 he was received on trial as a minister in the North Carolina Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church, South. In his first year in the active ministry, he was assigned to the Guilford Circuit. Between 1845 and 1850 he served churches in Greensboro, Beaufort, Plymouth, and Whiteville. Afterwards he succeeded to the largest churches in North Carolina Methodism at Washington, New Bern, Wilmington, Wilson, Raleigh, and Fayetteville. He was examined before a committee of clergymen at the December 1860 meeting of the church's North Carolina Conference and approved to be made an elder.

In 1868 Tucker was serving as the presiding elder of the New Bern District when his ministerial career came to an abrupt end. The official record for the year merely notes, "Joel W. Tucker . . . was expelled for immorality." His whereabouts thereafter are unknown. But by the time of his dismissal, he had become one of the more prominent Methodist clergymen in North Carolina. In 1866, for example, when he was assigned to the Methodist church in Wilson, he was named to the Board of Missions and was also chosen to preach the funeral sermon of an elderly, highly respected clergyman.

His flash of brilliance came during the course of the Civil War, when he was located at the Methodist church in Fayetteville. In quick succession he gave three sermons that were published and distributed throughout the South as comforting, if stern, theological interpretations of the place of the Confederacy in divine history. In one of the sermons, God's Providence in War, delivered to his congregation in Fayetteville on Friday, 16 May 1862, a general Confederate fast day, Tucker saw the ongoing war as "a conflict of truth with error—of the Bible with Northern infidelity—of pure christianity with Northern fanaticism—of liberty with despotism—of right with might." In the next, God Sovereign and Man Free (1862), he prayed "for the success of our cause; for the triumph of our armies," arguing that God could "answer our petitions, because he has sovereign control of the bodies and souls of men." These two sermons expressed succinctly and clearly the epitome of Southern wartime religious ideology, making Tucker momentarily one of the most popular and lauded prophets of the wartime South. The third published sermon, Guilt and Punishment of Extortion, preached on 7 Sept. 1862, was directed at extortioners who caused serious price inflation and contributed to the scarcity of certain goods. Tucker suggested means of controlling them. All of these were printed in Fayetteville at the office of the Presbyterian, a journal of that denomination.

At the time of the 1850 census, when he was living in Plymouth, N.C., his wife was twenty-year-old Penelope, a native of North Carolina. No children were recorded.


Methodist Episcopal Church, South, Minutes of the Annual Conferences (1845–68).

Joel W. Tucker, God Sovereign and Men Free: A Discourse (1862), God's Providence in War: A Sermon Delivered . . . in Fayetteville, N.C., on Friday, May 16, 1862 (1862), and Guilt and Punishment of Extortion: A Sermon (1862).

Additional Resources:

West Market Street Methodist Episcopal Church, South (Greensboro, N.C.). West Market Street Methodist Episcopal Church, South: a history of its growth and influence for one hundred years from its foundation in 1830, until October 12th, 1930. Greensboro, N. C. [Published by Circle No. 6, Woman's Missionary Society]. 1934. (accessed March 26, 2014).

Loftin, Emily. History of Ann Street Methodist Church, Beaufort, North Carolina : organized 1778. [Beaufort, N.C. : Ann Street Methodist Church]. 1966. (accessed March 26, 2014).



Joel William Tucker was born April 28, 1823 in Halifax County, Virginia. Son of James Old Tucker (1789-1852) and Mary Light(d. 1867). He died September 4 1909 and is buried in Fairmont Cemetery in Camden, Preble County, Ohio.

Rev. J. Wm Tucker is my children's 3rd great grandfather; Penelope McDonald Bennett Tucker is their grandmother through the second of Rev. and Penelope's 7 children, Sally McDonald Tucker. I am in possession of Joel Wm Tucker's family bible. Family oral history indicates that Sally Tucker was institutionalized for mental illness and during this time she was divorced by Rev. Tucker who was subsequently excommunicated by the Methodist church. Census records from 1870 confirm a Penelope Tucker residing at North Carolina Insane Asylum. The family bible indicates Penelope also died in 1870. Rev. Tucker married Laura S. Crofton in 1869 according to the family bible. Family oral history says Rev. Tucker was ordained as a Universalist Minister probably in 1873.He settled with his new wife and children including on from his marriage to Penelope Bennett (Robert Deems) in Somers, Preble, Ohio where he lived until his death in 1909. Rev. Tucker was inducted into the American Academy of Sciences in 1878 (I am in possession of his induction letter) and wrote the short book "Atonement" published by the Universalist Publishing House as part of their Manuals of Faith and Duty in 1893, which is still in print. Although married three times and fathering 11 children, only one of his children, Sally McDonald Tucker produced grandchildren (5) through her marriage to Andrew Anderson Weatherford.

Add a comment

PLEASE NOTE: NCpedia provides the comments feature as a way for viewers to engage with the resources. Comments are not published until reviewed by NCpedia editors at the State Library of NC, and the editors reserve the right to not publish any comment submitted that is considered inappropriate for this resource. NCpedia will not publish personal contact information in comments, questions, or responses. If you would like a reply by email, note that some email servers, such as public school accounts, are blocked from accepting messages from outside email servers or domains. If you prefer not to leave an email address, check back at your NCpedia comment for a reply. Please allow one business day for replies from NCpedia. Complete guidelines are available at